**************************************************************************************
PRIVATE SECTOR RELIEF FOR DISASTER SITES,
A NATIONWIDE SYSTEM FOR SHIPPING RELIEF SUPPLIES
First application: Katrina ReKovery*
**************************************************************************************
STATUS (10-4)
Tim Barrett has chosen Ocean State Transportation to line up flatbeds. From Tucson to the gulf, the rate is $2,395 including fuel. From other locations it will be another rate. The billing process is yet to be worked out. But it looks like they want payment upfront. No new progress on California Pallet System. We let Tim know that many of the pallets need to be in the gulf by Thanksgiving. The United Way is nervous that if this takes off nationally that they won't have the staff to administer it. So we're discussing having the regional UW's administer shipment payments from their regions.
Now that the national system is starting to get launched, we can turn our focus to finding more donors. Lumberyards, window/door manufacturers, etc. While we do that, we need organizations in the gulf to start lining up $ for fuel for these donations. The Hancock County EOC warehouse is prepared for accept building materials. HANDS in Jackson is ready, too, as is IDTF in Biloxi. Supposedly FEMA monies are starting to break free. Catholic Charities has started handing out vouchers. Things are starting to move, kids! Let's try and get them the most we can for the money!
See other history below "Background".
Background:
THE NEED: A system by which donors can deliver relief supplies to disaster sites using “excess” capacity in the US trucking system for affordable charitable rates. This has been tried many times before, and we think that we’ve finally found a way that will work.
DONORS EXIST: All over the country donors have gathered relief/rebuilding supplies, including corporations which are able to “cull” product that not great for retail but perfectly suitable for rebuilding.
WAREHOUSES: In the gulf, warehouses are distributing supplies to the rebuilding groups. Most of warehouses have forklifts/loading docks. They often unload & locally distribute 5-10 trailer loads/day.
SHIPPING (ACROSS THE US) IS THE MISSING LINK
BACKGROUND: The Citizen Action Team (CAT, www.citizenactionteam.org) sought to ship supplies to the coast to supplement established relief teams. The United Way of Tri-County approached Barrett Logistics, a major logistics firm in the NorthEast. The owners of the company offered warehousing/palletizing services. But CAT needed trucking. So they approached a few friends and worked out a “business model” by to utilize “excess” capacity in the trucking “hub system”. UPS Freight (then Overnite) agreed to $50 per pallet from Barrett’s warehouse in Methuen, MA to locations in the gulf. $50 seems to be affordable for community groups, so that they could concentrate on gathering.
THE GOAL: NATIONWIDE SYSTEM FOR SHIPPING HUMANITARIAN SUPPLIES: Replicate this business model or something like it for other regions of the US. Use capacity in the US manufacturing and logistics system without adding the margins of a large administrative/management organization to administer such a system. By not being an “organization”, the system would not be subject to the kinds of redtape which wastes so much of our charity resources.
THE PROPOSED TEMPLATE: Existing commercial systems deliver relief supplies with a low-hassle factor, for a price that community groups can afford.
- incoming warehouses “donate” their time/space (up to two semi-loads per warehouse)
- truckers transport pallets in their empty capacity
- truckers are paid by the charity
- 100% of fuel donations go to truckers, zero fuel donations are used to support admin costs
- United Way and/or other charities act as “bankers” for donations provided for fuel
- donated supplies are deemed to be of “zero value” and donors must remove donations immediately if a warehouse decides not to participate any longer
Ideally, we’ll have a template/business model for the nation. A national template would lessen the administration, and reduce the number of issues because the rules would be consistent region to region.
THE CURRENT SYSTEM: 6 players
1. Donors (see http://dbase.citizenactionteam.org, for a sample list. But there are many, many more)
- donors are “trained” to understand “the rules”
i. send only donations currently listed as “needed” and have a confirmed destination
ii. approved box sizes, packed properly and labeled
iii. warehouse “rules” (i.e. hours, etc) and etiquette
2. Incoming warehouse (currently just Barrett, Methuen, MA)
- stores and palletizes donations
- labels/loads pallets into trucks, when there is room on the trucks
- confirms with CAT that the pallets went into the truck
3. Truckers (currently just UPS Freight, previously Overnite)
- take the pallets through the hub system to the relief destination warehouse
- bills the “Banker”
4. Relief Warehouse (see www.citizenactionteam.org, “Resource Database”)
- receives, sorts, distribute
5. Banker (currently just the United Way)
- The Banker gets the invoices from the Truckers
- checks with Regional Administrator to ensure that deliveries were made and pays Trucker
- Gathers $ donations from donors that want to donate $. Donors can get the tax deduction.
6. Regional Administrator (regional “coordinator” of the relief hub system)
- trains donors and resolves issues if the donors are not following the rules
- prepares shipping docs
- confirms that deliveries were made and maintains tracking sheet
WHY THIS CAN WORK:
- The system has a history of success
- The donors that will “trial” the system have a history of success delivering supplies to the gulf
- More donors exist (see http://dbase.citizenactionteam.org, “Loads” for a partial list).
- The tracking tools have a history of success (see https://reliefdb.org) in ensuring that donations go only where they are needed
- The warehouses/local distribution systems in the gulf are ready and have a history of success.
- The project manager has experience working with teamsters and warehouse systems and has a long history of project management success
WHAT THIS COULD MEAN FOR THE FUTURE
- Better use of charity dollars
- More effective relief supply tracking
- Better use of volunteer time
- Spur donations because people can see where the donations go and can even choose the location
HOW MUCH VOLUME?
We want to start small to achieve a low-hassle factor in regions outside of the NorthEast. We want to start at one location and move a couple pallets and see how it works. Then send a few more pallets at that location, while spreading out to do the 2-pallet test at several other locations. Eventually, we want to start moving flatbeds, as well. We currently have about 20 flatbeds of donations, like lumber, roofing, doors, windows, etc. ready to go in various locations (see the database for a partial list). Based on our research, we believe that donors would be able to donate one or two flatbeds/week/region. It is possible that this volume could go up drastically, when an affordable shipping solution exists.
We are developing a "parts list" for a three bedroom home. This will be available soon.
ACTION ITEMS
- do whatever the national group wants us to do, in support of development of the concept
- get lumber companies lined up
- get article written about a life of service to motivate rich/semi-retired people to help
- track down building materials association people
- prepare presentation about the program
- prepare press materials
History:
STATUS 9/30
We had our meeting with the national level players on Monday. Usual administrative issues. Not much new, except that Tim Barrett wrote to the United Way after the meeting to say that he had a "Transportation Group" for the Tucson area. Not sure what that means. No other progress to report. See the history at the bottom to see the background. We're progressing with or without the national level players. Mike Sweeney to contact Christina at FreeHaul to investigate what the lumber is like. Mike may send a truck to get the stuff. I have Catholic Charities Christina's number also, as well as Ms White at the South MS clinic. They are working with Catholic Charities to get cases approved, just like everyone else.
STATUS (9/11/06)
We had our meeting with the national level players. It went quite well, mostly dealing with administrative issues around..."how to get stuff rolling now!" And we've made progress, in that people actually took specific action items relative to getting the pilot started, instead of just talking about what a pilot would look like.
Summary of the results:
Tucson, Lumber
The United Way has the money to pay for at least one lumber load, through Texas
UW. The national shipping guys have "devised" a system by which you get a
specific rate. And now it's a matter of getting the rate set and the billing specifics in order (I'm told it's $2,500 to the gulf). I'm also told that it will be "about a week" before the system is in place. Catholic Charities has expressed interest in paying for a secondload. They are in the middle of organizing how many houses they are going to fund in SouthWest MS. So it will be a couple of weeks before they can pay. The UW will be ready to pay as soon as the shipping system is in place and the specific trucking company identified. These are the companies that were talked about:
Old Dominion, Yellow, LandStar.
California, Pallets
The UW and/or Catholic Charities does not appear interested in paying for fuel for misc supplies.They seem to want to focus on lumber and building materials. BUT that seems OK for Schlene,who has money to ship pallets, at an affordable rate. The pallets system for Van Nuys (or nearby)
is getting set up right now. I'm told that it will be the same timeframe as with the lumber (about a week) before that system will be in place, but since I don't see a specific warehouse hub named,I'm wondering about the possibility of it happening in a week.
Rest of Country
They've decided to handle each "hub" on a case by case basis, based on the types of donations that are expected. For example, Tucson wants flatbeds. Box trucks/pallets are more appropriate for California. The group wants to start moving supplies from these two locations and then move out from there (that's not news, but that's what they've decided their idea is). So when I see them
actually getting things into trucks, I'll be lining up donations from the NorthWest lumber region, and large building materials manufacturers. I want to know that the process for adding a hub to the system isn't nearly as painful as setting up these first two.
Disclaimer: I would be careful to expect anything to roll within a week. BUT I would expect things to start rolling within a couple of weeks, IF this system happens. Of course, it's possible that this whole thing could blow up in our faces. But based on the conversations today, these people are hooked in to the highest levels of the shipping insdustry. If they can't do it, no one can.
Thank you all for your time and patience. We believe that this is an incredible opportunity to empower the relief system in America...and possibly the world.
STATUS (9/1/06)
We have been meeting with national level players who seem VERY interested in developing this system. These players have the ear of a the people that run the companies that we need to develop such a system. A second conference call resulted in the following action items:
- make list of corporations that we need at the table
- get shipping info for pilot loads: lumber/Tucson, school supplies/LA
- bios for regional hub managers
- job descriptions for key players
- flow chart (visual) for process
See list of "other, self-motivated action items" at the end of these notes.
Date of next meeting: 9/11 (ironically enough)